Review: A Star Is Born (2018)

A Star is Born (again) as Lady Gaga steals the show in Bradley Cooper's directorial debut.

- -

Film remakes can be a tricky act to undertake that will always inevitably be dogged by questions like “Will it be as good as the original(s)?”,  and of course “Why is this being made?”; though the concept of remakes isn’t new there seems to be a greater resurgence of the practice in the last few years, (especially from Disney) and so the announcement that a new version of A Star is Born was in production naturally garnered some skepticism. Yet for all the worry, audiences need not fret, for the 2018 version is not a simple retread or hackneyed story. Instead, they will be very pleasantly surprised to see not simply a remake, but an emotionally intelligent and entertaining film.

A Star Is Born Trailer

In his directorial debut, Bradley Cooper (who also stars and co-wrote the screenplay) took a considerable risk in choosing this particular title, yet his passion and heartfelt understanding of the material shines through and is one of the reasons why this 2018 version succeeds. Although many audiences may be familiar with the premise of A Star is Born ( after all it was first released in 1937, and remade in 1954 and 1976 with Judy Garland and Barbra Streisand respectively), Cooper has managed to not only modernize this tale for 21st-century viewers but ultimately retain a sense of timelessness. This is a story about human love, success, and tragedy that can never really age and in 2018 the movie shows it can still be fresh as well as classic.

Cooper assembles a strong cast of supporting actors that help bring forward this very heartfelt screenplay; add in an effective use of cinematographic shots of real-life concerts, with good use of shadows, lights, and close-ups, Mirroring the look of a rock documentary, A Star Is Born shines especially during the musical performances.

And besides his behind the scenes work, Bradley Cooper also excels in front of the camera as alcoholic country music star Jackson Maine, revealing a surprisingly good singing voice. Opposite Lady Gaga as fledgling singer/songwriter Ally, the main leads go beyond just having chemistry but musically their sharp and incisive lyrics really meld together seamlessly in their performances. There is a wonderfully natural and sympathetic tone in the character’s relationship (which extends to the supporting roles as well) where the act of acting takes a back seat to realistic personifications.

A Star Is Born Review Still 1
The Cooper / Gaga tandem works surprisingly well especially in the film’s musical moments

Lady Gaga is an obvious megastar in her own right, creates a very touching persona in Ally; filled with immense talent but still unsure of how the world would accept her, she finds a true knight in Jackson Maine despite his crippling personal demons.

Buy the ” A Star Is Born” soundtrack on Amazon

Unlike Gaga who has always been audacious in her performances and wardrobes, Ally is reserved and insecure. It shows a genuine acting talent from Gaga, who does indeed make it look easy. Perhaps there is a little bit of Ally in the real Lady Gaga, and why she is able to come alive on the screen in a most effective way. The performance is very real and never forced and together with Cooper’s charming and supportive Jackson, even in the face of his addictions, the on-screen ups and downs of the couple bring us along on a journey of emotion and inspiration.

Of course, as a musical, the song score of the film would be expected to play a central role and it does so excellently. Featuring songs written by Cooper, Gaga, country musician Lukas Nelson as well as other songwriters, the soundtrack of A Star is Born is as much an essential character as the others. Not only are the songs melodically pleasing and soaring tunes, but their sharp and incisive lyrics also compliment Ally’s and Jackson’s respective struggles.

Among the standout songs include the main theme “Shallow“, “Always Remember Us this Way” and “I’ll Never Love Again“, effective and beautiful compositions that should be considered strong contenders for awards recognition. A lovely rendition of the Edith Piaf classic “La Vie en Rose” also shows off Lady Gaga’s wide range of musicality.

A Star Is Born Review Still 2
We already knew Lady Gaga is already a star but as Ally she shows a side we haven’t seen from the pop icon

Featuring some interesting behind the scenes views of the music industry, A Star is Born does occasionally veer into predictable territory. As Ally’s star rises, Jackson’s begins to fade leading to a conclusion that some may spot from far away. But throughout its runtime the film remains consistently engaging, providing a rich tale of love, music, triumph, and hardship.

Though a remake, Bradley Cooper’s version of A Star is Born takes the basic human elements of the story and places it in a new era; but the timelessness of these emotions ensure that the movie feels both modern and nostalgic.  Anchored by compelling lead performances and a soundtrack that delivers as any good music should, this 2018 remake shows that, like its predecessors, it is an excellent and rewarding outing at the movies.


+ Timeless and classic themes + Strong lead performances + Excellent soundtrack - Occasionally predictable
Michael Vecchio
Michael Vecchio
Michael Vecchio is a contributing writer for Before The Cyborgs. A graduate of the University of Alberta, he is a keen follower of events in the world of film, as well as politics and history. You can also hear him podcast about film and politics



Love Like The Movies: In The Mood For Love (2000)

Wong Kar Wai's In The Mood For Love is a breathtaking exploration of the feeling of longing, of loneliness and the fleeting yet lingering feeling of love.

Review: Person to Person charms with understated stories of life-like characters.

A New York indie gem, melding wry humor, quiet drama, and thoughtful sentimentality. Person to Person is a thoughtful character study set under a beautiful New York backdrop

In Appreciation Of: The Before Trilogy

Capturing love at all stages, Richard Linklater's Before Trilogy may be the most encompassing depiction of love ever put to film

Review: The Florida Project Finds Truth And Beauty In The Shadow of Americana

Sean Baker once again spotlights America's underrepresented in a hard-hitting examination of life a few miles from the happiest place on earth

LEAKED: LaMarcus Aldridge Pitch Transcripts

We have the transcripts from the LaMarcus Aldridge free agency meetings

Related Articles

Making The Case: Darkest Hour For Best Picture

Gary Oldman is the heavy favorite in the Best Actor category but Darkest Hour's chances at winning Best Picture are much less optimistic. Here is the case for why that should change.

A Place Where Perfect Doesn’t Matter: Ah-Mer-Ah-Su’s Star

In addition to being an artifact of empowerment, this record is a sitting-on-the-stairs sort of honesty, a safe-keeping savvy of all the ways in which art can be a sort of communal celebration and preservation.

Love Like The Movies: Casablanca (1942)

It’s been called the quintessential Hollywood love story and now 75 years later it still remains better than ever. Like a fine wine, Casablanca is the type of film that only gets better with age.