Review: They Shall Not Grow Old

An astounding technical achievement in film restoration, Peter Jackson’s They Shall Not Grow Old is an emotionally superb embrace of those who made the ultimate sacrifice.

- Advertisement -

When the staggering number of casualties from the Great War became increasingly apparent to those back at home, English poet Laurence Binyon was so moved by the tragedy he created words that would be immortalized forever; “They shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old. Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn. At the going down of the sun and in the morning, we will remember them.”  

Although these feelings of remembrance are now used to commemorate the fallen of all global conflict, it was indeed the First World War (1914-1918), or “The War to End all Wars”, that inspired these heartbreakingly eloquent words and forever enshrined the memory of a lost generation for all time. With this spirit of remembrance and in further recognition of the centenary of the 1918 Armistice comes the latest directorial effort from Peter Jackson, in They Shall Not Grow Old, a striking, immersive and emotionally powerful documentary feature, unlike anything we’ve ever seen before.

Audiences have seen plenty a documentary on the War, as well as films, television shows, and countless other forms of literature, and so one may ask what can Jackson and his team really offer that has not been portrayed before? But this is not simply another recitation of statistics and ideological geopolitics, but an immensely personal and technically ground-breaking work of cinema, that is both visually stunning and incredibly emotionally intelligent.

Using only the narration of actual veterans alongside images of the War (soldier training at home, trench life, battle scenes, and graphic stills of the dead and wounded) we are presented with a literal front row seat to this calamitous war filled with the personal anecdotes of those who were there; there are no historians, children of veterans and other service members speaking, only the people who knew the realities of the Western Front firsthand.

From the tales of food shortages and diseases in the trench, the horrific smell of death all around, and the struggle to find understanding amidst all the chaos, these stories are all the more poignant as they are juxtaposed with images from the front lines. This is not your typical black and white, grainy old footage, however; indeed it is the utterly magnificent restoration and colorization of this 100-year-old film that truly makes these stories jump to life. So striking and beautiful is the restoration, that for the first time we see the Great War not as something from a textbook but as a contemporary and very real struggle.

They Shall Not Grow Old Still 3
Before and After Restoration

SO STRIKING AND BEAUTIFUL IS THE RESTORATION, THAT FOR THE FIRST TIME WE SEE THE GREAT WAR NOT AS SOMETHING FROM A TEXTBOOK BUT AS A CONTEMPORARY AND VERY REAL STRUGGLE.

Jackson has thus created a brilliant resurrection of the past in such vivid detail, it hardly seems that the men and voices we see and hear existed 100 years ago. In one scene a group of soldiers is shown hiding in a ravine, likely awaiting orders to attack, and the scope of the emotions on their faces tells the whole story; later in a post-credits commentary we learn that that particular footage was the last film ever shot of those men, who were all killed just 30 minutes after being filmed. With this vivacity it becomes even more saddening to think that all these individuals who are shown (with all their loves, fears and emotions) have now passed on, but forever leaving their marks on us.

Sifting through close to 600 hours of film footage of the war and interviews with veterans, Jackson and the crew were met with a massive undertaking, yet took on the challenge with an immense reverence. The meticulousness is not just in the coloring and restoring this footage, but also in adding authentic sounds, speeches from the soldiers (determined by lip reading the silent film), and adjusting the frame rate from reels of damaged film, what has been accomplished technically in this movie is an absolute marvel in every sense of that word.  It is a breathtaking and graphic depiction of events in a way we could never have imagined. Perhaps reading about the piles of young men massacred could provide a vivid image for some, but with this film, it’s clear no imagination is needed to realize the raw brutality of this real-life butcher shop.

With these amazing testimonials (which are also occasionally amusing, “When will we have strawberries?!”) supported by footage long thought to be unusable, They Shall Not Grow Old relies on the soldiers themselves to greatly humanize the First World War; although it is told through the perspective of British soldiers only, we can assume that the universal human emotions felt by these young men would be the same for the German and other enemy sides, and so the stories and graphic shots presented really don’t belong to just the British, but to all who lived, died, and ultimately survived.

They Shall Not Grow Old Still 1

The film should not be viewed as an academic study of the War, but rather as a highly personable and emotional view of those who knew it best. Peter Jackson and his team proclaim here that it makes no difference who fired the first and last shot, who was assassinated and who gave what order, rather it is the human toll and their unique experiences that continue to resonate now and forever. Along this narrative path and with truly extraordinary feats in film and audio restoration, They Shall Not Grow Old is more than just a documentary but a solemn embrace of a lost generation, who once more implore us from beyond the grave to stop the fighting. As Laurence Binyon wrote, “To the end, to the end, they remain.”

- Advertisement -
+ Stunning film restoration and colorization + Emotional first-hand accounts from soldiers + Very personal and striking narrative

READ MORE

Best A24 Movie – BTC Staff Survey

Each week the Before The Cyborgs staff comes together to answer one question relating to the current events of that particular week.  This week with the upcoming release of A24’s First Reformed - we ask: What is your favorite A24 Film?

In Just 2 and a Half Minutes, Toy Story Perfectly Captures The Existential Crisis

Toy Story captures the feeling of an existential crisis in just two and a half minutes and it allows many feelings to surface

Manchester By The Sea Review

Manchester by the Sea is a tale of great sadness and redemption; managing to show that hope in tomorrow will always live if we find a place for it.

Epic Episodes: “Goodbyeee” (Blackadder Goes Forth)

Goodbyeee melds Blackadder's biting satire with very incisive bits on the meaning of war, the ineptitude of the commanders, and the colossal waste of life.

Nippon Double Trifecta: Six Exciting Acts From Japan!

Every third article is a triple feature. With Japan, I hit the 2x multiplier! Here's 6 incredible acts from the archipelago.
Michael Vecchio
Michael Vecchiohttp://beforethecyborgs.com
Michael Vecchio is a contributing writer for Before The Cyborgs. A graduate of the University of Alberta, he is a keen follower of events in the world of film, as well as politics and history. You can also hear him podcast about film and politics