Edge of Seventeen Review

- -



In the 1980s filmmaker, John Hughes produced a series of teen films that not only provided audiences with laughs but produced a surprisingly complex emotional connection to its characters that shed some spotlight on what it meant to be a young person. Since that time there have been only a select few films that have reached the cinematic quality of Hughes’ work in the teenage dramedy genre; alas writer-director Kelly Fremon Craig’s The Edge of Seventeen takes up the legacy of the late great Hughes and offers a wonderfully funny, touching and witty film accentuated by an outstanding lead performance by Hailee Steinfeld.

For 17 year old Nadine (Steinfeld) life could not be any more difficult; socially awkward amongst her classmates (despite her obvious maturity and keen perception into things) and insecure in her appearance her already tumultuous world is turned upside when her all-star brother Darian begins to date her best and only friend Krista (Haley Lu Richardson). Add to the mix Nadine’s struggle to get the attention of her crush and her widowed mother Mona’s attempts to get back in the dating scene and it seems like this 17-year-olds daily existence is a never-ending nightmare.

Hailee Steinfeld is a revelation and delivers a great and touching depiction of teen angst and self-doubt; she is not only skillfully funny and wonderfully sarcastic but convincingly vulnerable. In the hands of another, this sharp script may have fallen flat, but Steinfeld commands the screen when she is on it and makes Nadine a truly sympathetic character even through all her quirks. Acclaimed for her other performances including True Grit in which she received an Oscar nomination for Supporting Actress, The Edge of Seventeen is a shining vehicle for her talents; a nomination perhaps this time in the Best Actress category would certainly be a very welcome and deserving gesture.

While Steinfeld makes the most of this fine script, Kelly Fremon Craig must also be praised not solely for her direction (her directorial debut) but indeed in creating this witty and emotional screenplay. Like Diablo Cody’s screenplay for Juno, Craig has crafted a work that touches exactly on the themes John Hughes so masterfully did over 30 years ago. There is humor, wit, genuine pathos and that ever-present vulnerability that populated so many of Hughes’ characters; it’s not just Nadine, but Krista, Darian, Mona and others that are very real in their characterization and make that connection to the audience. Insert a remarkable deadpan turn from Woody Harrelson as Nadine’s history teacher and we have a cast of characters and situations that make us laugh, feel sad and remind us that no matter how bad we may think our lives are, there is always someone who has it worse.


The Edge of Seventeen belongs to a genre of films about teenage uncertainty, but unlike so many of them, it has the distinction of being an astute, touching and funny film. With a solidly crafted screenplay and an outstanding lead from Hailee Steinfeld, the film transcends the clichés and stereotypes of some teen movies and instead produces an entertaining and poignant commentary on the precarious time between adolescence and adulthood. If John Hughes could share his thoughts on it I’m certain he would be most pleased and know that the work he began decades ago can still be as fresh and relevant today.

Michael Vecchio
Michael Vecchiohttp://beforethecyborgs.com
Michael Vecchio is a contributing writer for Before The Cyborgs. A graduate of the University of Alberta, he is a keen follower of events in the world of film, as well as politics and history. You can also hear him podcast about film and politics



Review: The Mule

Neither Clint Eastwood nor The Mule itself are the flashiest or most sophisticated effort you'll ever see but the familiarity of their approach lends itself to a satisfying result nonetheless

In Appreciation Of: Marty (1955)

Whether you are spending Valentine's Day alone or with a partner. Marty (1955) is an under the radar film worth seeking out

The Unmade Biopics We Would Like To See – BTC Staff Survey

The BTC Staff weighs in on which biopics they would like to see made in the future and who they would like to star in them.

Review: Beauty And The Beast (2017) Pales in Comparison to the Animated Classic

Beauty And The Beast is a remake that has its moments but pales in comparison to its animated counterpart as it fails to hit the same emotional resonance.

Searching For My Big Fish Moment

Examining a scene from Tim Burton's Big Fish and whether the past really is just a story we tell ourselves.

Related Articles

Tim Curry Retrospective – A Legacy of Character Greatness

Profiling the diverse career of Tim Curry that has made him a cult icon with roles like Pennywise and Dr. Frank N. Furter

Mickey Mouse At 90: The World’s Most Famous Mouse

M-I-C-K-E-Y M-O-U-S-E. Celebrating the legacy of Mickey Mouse who turns 90.

Predicting Nominations For 2018 Oscars

Who will wake up to the news that they have been nominated for an Oscar? Our staff weighs in with our nomination predictions for the 90th Academy Awards